After we finished he said, “Let’s read the whole thing again right now.” I know he doesn’t have the attention span for that. I had to do a little bit of explaining here and there to make sure he knew what was going on, but he says he liked it. Each chapter took about 10 minutes which is about the limit of his attention span at the moment. However, while the plot was very simple, the language was a little bit advanced and the chapters were slightly longer than what we’ve been reading. It’s strange, though, because on the one hand, it was way shorter than I was expecting (only four chapters long). The New York Times Parent’s Guide to the Best Books for ChildrenĬomments: I just finished reading this book to my 4.5 year old and I think it was a good book for his age.Valerie and Walter’s Best Books for Children.Definately, if you get one of the books, get them all, because they are so small, and after you finish the first, you are ready for the others.Website: Age Group: Kindergarten, Early Elementary It would be ideal to get all four books in one set, but that seems to be hard to find these days. I think of the old “See Dick Run” books, and wish that all early readers could be as imaginative as these. Written with simplicity, both in language and plot, they are very easy to follow. These are great read aloud books, and also easy books for a new reader who might want to read them on their own.

enough so that I decided against reading it to my five-year-old grandson, but by six or seven, no problem. The stories also have a slight amount of scary parts. These are all pretty hefty themes for such little tales. And the Alexander story very deftly deals with how a child/kitten might handle trauma. In the second book, a kitten gets separated from her mother and gets quite frightened. In the first book, the cat children leave their mother, at her request. In addition to the imaginative aspect, each of the stories also deals with a potentially difficult theme for a child to deal with. It’s just real enough to be true to life, and then, that extra little thing, a wing! The settings are real, the troubles of the cats are real, and the fact that the cats have wings and can fly…well, perhaps that’s a stretch! What a wonderful way to weave fantasy into stories. This set of stories, beginning with Catwings, continuing with Catwings Return, Wonderful Alexander and the Catwings, and Jane on Her Own, are the perfect mixture of fantasy and realism. In four small children’s books, Ursula Le Guin has created a very endearing set of cat characters with personality, adventure, and wisdom. Jane Tabby could not explain why all four of her children had wings.”

Catwings ursula